Skip to content
Freshly Daily

The App's Most Dedicated Critics Are Altering Film-Going Norms: I Couldn't Wait to Pull Out My Phone'

I consistently completely turn off my phone upon entering a cinema. Not just on do not disturb – totally powered down. I mention this not from a place of judgment, or in the hope that the spirit of a film legend will materialize to offer approval. I consider it as a genuine minor indulgences: for at least ninety minutes, I become completely disconnected. I keep my phone off for the duration of the scroll as well. It strikes me as decadent to remain seated as the audience gradually exit, lit only by the scrolling names.

And, lately, by the light of the cataloguing app.

More than millions of individuals engage with Letterboxd, a movie-logging platform. Similar to A24, it has transformed into industry shorthand for a particular kind of influencer who champions new releases and finds joy in unearthing vintage films. Members rate and review films, and the funniest or most articulate reviews become popular, incentivizing movie buffs to craft thoughtful responses.

"Should I fail to get my thoughts out immediately when the film concludes, my reviews are far less clear and eloquent," remarked Josh Stern.

In a recent outing to the theater, the end titles had just begun before the gentleman ahead of me commenced writing his assessment. Not far away, a pair remained seated, focused on their screens, recording their individual impressions.

The renowned film-maker David Lynch had a piece of guidance: note every brilliant thought the very second it occurs to you. If you don't, it could vanish, and, as he put it: "If you forget a good idea, you want to commit suicide." While Lynch spoke to budding directors, a similar ethos fits the post-film ritual.

A student, a 20-year-old university attendee in New York, without fail composes his assessments from his theater seat.

"Unless I jot down my ideas promptly after the credits roll, my critiques are significantly less clear and eloquent," he said. "It takes a bit. I'm pretty slow, and my significant other gets impatient."

He visits the movies a great deal – 182 visits last year – and is on a first-name basis with the ushers, who occasionally have to ask him to leave so they can commence sweeping the theater. He believes it perfectly fair to utilize the credit sequence: "Upon buying a cinema ticket, the credits are included in the feature."

Letterboxd's most fervent advocates credit the app with reinvigorating interest around a battered film industry, where output has decreased and joblessness is high. (Letterboxd also has the type of user profile advertisers seek – its biggest cohort of users is aged 18 and 24, followed by 25 to 35.)

Buzz creates more hype; eagerly anticipated movies experience a surge of engagement on Letterboxd shortly following the initial screenings. The top review of an acclaimed movie – "the author succumbed centuries ago yet this adaptation is still the worst thing that has ever happened to her" – has garnered in excess of 50,000 double-taps. A different fictionalized retelling produced this juxtaposition to a pop star's concert film: "the Eras Tour documentary left in the dust."

"It's somewhat a compulsion," said one user, a thirty-three-year-old New Yorker who has a career in marketing. He also chooses to write reviews throughout the end sequence. "Thinking about what you just saw, immediately after you experienced it, helps with the viewing experience. It helps you grasp the central themes of a film. If it produces a feeling of comfort, that's not always something you remember hours later."

Glidden feels most driven to write about a film if it was exceptionally good – or terrible. For example: he recently sat through a star-driven project. "I found myself so offended by how utterly terrible it was, that I was eager to pull out my phone and give it a lowest possible rating," he said. (This reviewer is a tougher evaluator than other film critics, who assigned the film a higher rating, describing it as "smart and entertaining stuff.")

Dakota Chester, a twenty-eight-year-old professional who works in social media, saw a fantasy feature at a cinema on the Upper West Side and remained to compose the assessment ("it got the highest rating"). He has witnessed poorer etiquette: people whipping out their phones to review the movie they are currently watching. "That annoys me," he commented.

One of the movie industry's longest-running tales tells of a screening of an early silent short that featured a train entering a station. The medium was in its formative period and – according to this debunked story – the footage of a locomotive heading straight toward the camera frightened the crowd so much that people fled screaming.

A hundred and thirty years later, audience behavior is just as questionable. Often, individuals remember how to behave in a theater anymore, notably when the lights go down: viewers take pictures of the projection, bring in odorous food, and, as seen during a recent cinematic event, at times engage in outright brawls.

Some individuals have resorted to social media to debate the appropriateness of "Letterboxding" in the end sequence. When one social media user

By

Nicholas Perez

Maya Sterling is a lifestyle writer and wellness coach passionate about helping others find joy in everyday moments.

Freshly Daily

Type to search articles.